What Happens to an Industry When Its Best Professionals Can No Longer Afford to Stay
Recently, I read a post from a horse professional who described watching four people she knew announce the closure of their barns in a single day. The businesses were unrelated, but the reasons for closing were remarkably similar. Financial pressure, exhaustion, difficult client relationships, and the growing realization that the personal sacrifices required to keep their businesses operating were no longer sustainable.
Four closures don't establish an industry-wide trend, and there are many reasons why people decide to close a business. Still, the post raised a question I've been thinking about for a long time. What happens to the equestrian industry when experienced professionals, people who have devoted much of their lives to developing the knowledge and skills our industry depends upon, can no longer afford to remain in it?
The Investment Behind Professional Expertise
When an experienced horse professional closes their business, the immediate consequences are fairly visible. Horses must be relocated, clients need new trainers or boarding arrangements, and employees may lose their jobs. What is much harder to measure is the accumulated expertise that may be leaving the industry along with that professional.
Developing a knowledgeable horse professional is a long and expensive process, although much of that investment never appears on a balance sheet. Consider how many horses an accomplished trainer or instructor may have ridden, trained, cared for, or managed over the course of a career. Think about the different trainers they've worked with, the lessons they've taken, the competitions they've attended, and the variety of horses and situations they've encountered.
Then consider the veterinary and farrier knowledge they've absorbed through years of managing horses, observing problems firsthand, working alongside specialists, and seeing how different decisions affect outcomes over time. Much of this knowledge comes from experience that cannot be replicated in a classroom. The ability to recognize a subtle change in a horse's behavior, anticipate a training problem, or understand when something isn't quite right often reflects years of exposure to situations that a less experienced professional has simply never encountered.
Acquiring this expertise requires an enormous investment of time, labor, money, and opportunity. Some professionals have had access to exceptional horses and mentors, while others have made substantial personal and financial sacrifices to obtain the experience they need. The investment is made not only by the professional, but also by the trainers who mentor them, the owners who provide opportunities, and the businesses where they develop their skills.
When an accomplished professional leaves the industry, we lose more than the services they currently provide. We lose some of the accumulated value of those experiences, along with opportunities for that knowledge to be passed on to the next generation.
The Economics of Expertise
The equestrian industry places enormous value on experience, at least in principle. We admire accomplished trainers, knowledgeable instructors, exceptional horsepeople, and professionals who have dedicated their lives to mastering their craft. Yet there's often a disconnect between the value we place on expertise and the business structures through which that expertise is delivered.
Many horse professionals operate businesses that depend heavily on their personal labor. Their earning capacity is constrained by the number of horses they can train, lessons they can teach, or clients they can serve. Meanwhile, the cost of horses, facilities, insurance, labor, equipment, and other operating expenses continues to place pressure on their margins.
Taking on additional horses or clients may increase revenue, but it can also increase costs, workload, and operational complexity. At some point, growth can actually make the business less sustainable, particularly when the owner is already working at or beyond their personal capacity.
There's also a distinction between a business generating enough revenue to pay its bills and generating enough profit to adequately compensate its owner. A professional may appear to operate a successful business while earning very little relative to the hours worked, responsibilities assumed, and capital invested. If the business cannot provide for reasonable compensation, time away, savings, and future financial security, its long-term sustainability deserves closer examination.
For many trainers, income from horse sales, sales commissions, and horse show training fees can make a significant contribution to profitability. These are legitimate and potentially valuable parts of the business model, but they shouldn't be relied upon to compensate for consistently inadequate margins in the core operation. When the day-to-day business doesn't generate sufficient income to support its operating costs and adequately compensate the professional, a good sales year or a busy show season can mask underlying financial problems rather than solve them.
Of course, some horse professionals have developed highly successful businesses, and some markets support substantial fees for specialized expertise. Understanding why those businesses work is important. But we also need to recognize that not every market, service, or business model provides the same opportunities.
When Expertise Becomes a Commodity
In my recent article, What Happens When We Commoditize Riding?, I explored the potential consequences of treating riding instruction, instructors, and school horses as increasingly interchangeable components of a scalable business model.
But commoditization isn't limited to riding lessons. It can occur whenever clients have difficulty distinguishing the value of one professional's services from another's, and price or convenience becomes the primary basis for comparison.
This presents a particular challenge in an industry where so much of the value lies in judgment, experience, relationships, and the quality of decisions made over time. Two training programs may look similar on a price list while delivering very different levels of expertise, individual attention, horse management, and long-term results.
Clients cannot always evaluate those differences easily, particularly before they've experienced the service. And professionals who struggle to communicate what distinguishes their work may find themselves competing primarily on price, even when the value they provide is substantially different.
Standardization and efficient business practices are not inherently problematic. In fact, good systems can improve service quality, consistency, and profitability. The concern arises when efficiency and interchangeability become more important than the expertise and individual judgment required to deliver an excellent service.
If our industry increasingly rewards what is easiest to package and sell, rather than the depth of knowledge behind the service, we risk undermining the economic value of the expertise we depend upon.
This Is More Than a Burnout Problem
Burnout is real, and the physical and emotional demands of working with horses can be considerable. But I think we need to be careful about treating the departure of experienced professionals primarily as a personal wellness problem.
Sometimes the underlying business model doesn't generate enough income to support the people doing the work. Sometimes pricing hasn't kept pace with the actual cost of delivering the service. Sometimes the business depends so heavily on the owner's personal involvement that taking time away means losing income. And sometimes client expectations or established industry practices make necessary changes difficult to implement.
These are economic and organizational challenges that cannot be resolved simply by encouraging professionals to work fewer hours or establish better boundaries. Nor can every problem be solved by raising prices. Sustainable businesses require an appropriate relationship between their markets, services, pricing, operating costs, and the resources needed to deliver what they promise.
We also need to distinguish between professionals who leave because they've chosen a different direction and those who leave because they cannot find an economically sustainable way to continue doing work they value. The first is a normal part of any industry. The second deserves much closer attention.
What Kind of Industry Are We Building?
The consequences of losing experienced professionals extend well beyond individual barns. Trainers, instructors, barn owners, and other horse professionals help develop the horses, riders, clients, and future professionals upon whom the rest of the equestrian economy depends.
They also provide continuity. They mentor younger professionals, introduce newcomers to the sport, maintain relationships with owners, veterinarians, farriers, and other service providers, and contribute to the networks of knowledge and experience that support the industry.
If fewer people can build financially sustainable careers, the effects may not be immediately apparent. But over time, we risk reducing the opportunities available to acquire advanced skills, gain meaningful experience, and learn from accomplished professionals.
I don't believe there's a single business model or industry initiative that will resolve these challenges. Horse professionals serve different markets and operate under very different circumstances. But I do believe we need to take a more serious look at the relationship between professional expertise, business economics, and the future of our industry.
We need to help clients recognize the value of expertise and support professionals in developing businesses that reflect both their standards and their economic realities.
The equestrian industry depends on an extraordinary depth of specialized knowledge, much of it developed over decades and at considerable personal investment. If we want that knowledge to remain available to future generations of horses and riders, we need to care about whether the people who possess it can afford to stay.
The sustainability of horse professionals isn't simply an individual business concern. It's a question about the future capacity and health of the entire equestrian industry.
We need to help clients recognize the value of expertise and support professionals in developing businesses that reflect both their standards and their economic realities. Accomplishing that may require greater cooperation among professionals within different segments of the equestrian industry. By identifying shared challenges, developing stronger professional standards, and communicating more consistently about the value and responsibilities of their work, these groups may be better positioned to change expectations that individual businesses struggle to address on their own.
Not yet a member?
Equestrian Professional offers different levels of resources and support depending on what you need. Resource Membership provides access to our extensive library of horse business tools, webinars, articles and guides. Professional Membership adds Group Coaching, Horse Business Review & Planning and special events. Private Advisory provides ongoing one-to-one consulting. Private Consulting and Strategic Consulting are also available when you need focused or more in-depth support.
